Following up on the other movies and Husker & HPark's thoughts, Running With Scissors should be an Over, and the line is at takeable odds. This is a decent play because RWS already opened, so we kinda know how it's going to do. There is historical precedent for how limited release movies open. Even with bad reviews, RWS should go Over based on how these things expand.
To go Over, RWS needs $3 mil in 586 theaters, which means a 5.1k PTA, which means it needs to hold 18% of its $28.3k opening PTA last week. To see if it can do this, here are some limited-release comps.
The following movies are not exact comps as far as movies go, but show how limiteds expand. As long as the limiteds keep 18% of their initial PTA, then the Over is good. Most of these did not expand much until the 3rd or 4th week. RWS is expanding in its 2nd week, so it's % hold should be even better than these comps.
The 4 best comps (R rated adult movies in Oct-Dec with decent casts) did 18-30% holds over several weeks, with the week-to-week holds being 40-70%.
An average 22.5% hold would give RWS a $6.4k PTA for a $3.7 mil opening. Better than this should be expected due to expansion in its 2nd week, so fewer drops.
-----
Life as a House, R, 10/20/01, 10.1k PTA in 29 theaters, 2nd week 6.6k PTA in 88 theaters (65% hold), 3rd week 3.0k PTA in 1,288 theaters (45% hold). 30% overall hold from initial opening to semi-wide expansion.
Shopgirl, R, 10/21/05, 28.8k PTA in 8 theaters, 2nd week 11.0k PTA in 42 theaters (38% hold), 3rd week 5.1k PTA in 493 theaters (46% hold). 18% overall hold from initial release to semi-wide expansion.
Royal Tenenbaums, R, 12/14/01, 55.4k in 5t, 31.7k in 40t (57%), 17.0k in 291t (54%), 11.3k in 751t (66%). 20% hold from init to s-w.
About Schmidt, R, 12/13/02, 47.0k in 6t, 23.1k in 26t (49%), 2 weeks later 10.5k in 816t (45%). 22% from init to s-w.